Reviewer Guideline

Introduction:

Thank you for agreeing to review a manuscript for The International Journal of Strategic Research and Review (IJSRR-CISR). Your expertise and insights are invaluable in maintaining the journal's high standards of academic rigor and contributing to the advancement of knowledge. These guidelines are designed to assist you in providing a comprehensive and constructive review.

Purpose of Review:

The primary purpose of the peer review process is to assess the quality, originality, and significance of the submitted manuscript. Your review should focus on providing feedback that helps authors improve their work and assists the editors in making informed decisions regarding publication.

Review Criteria:

Please address the following criteria in your review:

  1. Originality and Significance:
    • Is the research novel and original?
    • Does the manuscript contribute significantly to the existing body of knowledge?
    • Is the research question clearly defined and relevant?
  2. Methodology:
    • Are the research methods appropriate and sound?
    • Is the methodology clearly described and justified?
    • Are the data analysis and interpretation accurate and reliable?
  3. Literature Review:
    • Is the literature review comprehensive and relevant?
    • Does the manuscript adequately acknowledge and synthesize previous research?
    • Are the citations accurate and complete?
  4. Clarity and Organization:
    • Is the manuscript clearly written and well-organized?
    • Is the language appropriate for an academic audience?
    • Are the tables and figures clear and informative?
  5. Ethical Considerations:
    • Does the manuscript adhere to ethical guidelines for research involving human or animal subjects?
    • Are there any concerns regarding plagiarism or data fabrication?
    • Has any conflict of interest been disclosed?
  6. Relevance to IJSRR-CISR Scope:
    • Does the article fit within the scope and focus of the journal?
    • Does the article contribute to strategic research, innovation, or leadership?

Review Process:

  1. Confidentiality:
    • Maintain the confidentiality of the review process.
    • Do not share the manuscript or your review with anyone outside of the editorial team.
  2. Timeliness:
    • Please submit your review within the agreed-upon timeframe.
    • If you are unable to meet the deadline, please inform the editorial office as soon as possible.
  3. Constructive Feedback:
    • Provide specific and constructive feedback to the authors.
    • Focus on the strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript.
    • Offer suggestions for improvement.
  4. Objective Evaluation:
    • Provide an objective evaluation of the manuscript, free from personal bias.
    • Base your assessment on the quality of the research and its contribution to the field.
  5. Comments to Authors and Editors:
    • Provide separate comments to the authors and the editors.
    • In your comments to the authors, provide detailed feedback on the manuscript.
    • In your comments to the editors, provide your overall assessment and recommendation (e.g., accept, revise, reject).
  6. Recommendation:
    • Provide a clear recommendation to the editors regarding the manuscript's suitability for publication.
    • Recommendations may include:
      • Accept without revision
      • Accept with minor revisions
      • Revise and resubmit
      • Reject

Review Format:

Please provide your review in a structured format, including:

  1. Summary of the Manuscript: A brief summary of the manuscript's purpose, methods, and key findings.
  2. Overall Assessment: An overall assessment of the manuscript's strengths and weaknesses.
  3. Specific Comments: Detailed comments on each section of the manuscript, including suggestions for improvement.
  4. Recommendation: Your recommendation to the editors.

Ethical Guidelines for Reviewers:

  • Declare any conflict of interest that may influence your review.
  • Avoid using information from the manuscript for your own research before publication.
  • Maintain impartiality and objectivity in your review.

Submission of Review:

Please submit your review through the journal's online review system or by email to the editorial office at review@cisr.online

Contact Information:

If you have any questions or require further assistance, please contact the editorial office at editor@cisr.online

Thank you for your valuable contribution to IJSRR-CISR.